Arthur C Clarke
Mar 2005
A wonderful introduction, but not as satisfying as the series that follows.
Brian K Vaughan
Jul 2008
Not the most satisfying of endings, but overall one of the best graphic novel series I have read to date.
Geroge RR Martin
Mar 2008
Hard to root or care for a ridiculously unlikeable character.
John Scalzi
May 2008
Scalzi's sense of humor mixed with his gift for storytelling makes for one hell of a sequel.
John Scalzi
May 2008
The return of main series protagonist Jon Perry pleased me greatly.
John Scalzi
Jan 2008
A unique premise in literary science fiction? That's crazy talk.
Mick Harrison
Sep 2008
Why am I even bothering with the SW universe anymore?
Orson Scott Card
Mar 2008
A great many words can't make up for the lack of a good story.
Orson Scott Card
Feb 2008
A long overdue read for me, but well worth the wait. Starting and ending the series with this book would not be a horrible call.
Orson Scott Card
May 2008
Losing complete interest in this universe.
Robert Kirkman
May 2008
Sweet Zombie Jesus, yes.
Robert Kirkman
Sep 2008
Not the best in the series by far, but obviously the calm before the storm.
Robert Kirkman
Sep 2008
Sweet Jesus...
Steve Perry
May 2008
A fun return to the Matador universe I had discovered as a kid, but standard Perry otherwise.